Carthage vs Git Submodules
Developers should use Carthage when they need a lightweight, non-intrusive dependency manager for Swift or Objective-C projects, especially in environments where they want to avoid modifying Xcode project files or prefer decentralized dependency management meets developers should use git submodules when they need to incorporate external libraries, frameworks, or shared components into their main project while keeping those dependencies as separate repositories with their own version history. Here's our take.
Carthage
Developers should use Carthage when they need a lightweight, non-intrusive dependency manager for Swift or Objective-C projects, especially in environments where they want to avoid modifying Xcode project files or prefer decentralized dependency management
Carthage
Nice PickDevelopers should use Carthage when they need a lightweight, non-intrusive dependency manager for Swift or Objective-C projects, especially in environments where they want to avoid modifying Xcode project files or prefer decentralized dependency management
Pros
- +It is ideal for projects that require binary frameworks for faster build times or when integrating with CI/CD pipelines that benefit from pre-built dependencies
- +Related to: swift, objective-c
Cons
- -Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case
Git Submodules
Developers should use Git Submodules when they need to incorporate external libraries, frameworks, or shared components into their main project while keeping those dependencies as separate repositories with their own version history
Pros
- +Common use cases include managing third-party dependencies, sharing common code across multiple projects, or working on large, modular applications where different teams maintain separate repositories
- +Related to: git, version-control
Cons
- -Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case
The Verdict
Use Carthage if: You want it is ideal for projects that require binary frameworks for faster build times or when integrating with ci/cd pipelines that benefit from pre-built dependencies and can live with specific tradeoffs depend on your use case.
Use Git Submodules if: You prioritize common use cases include managing third-party dependencies, sharing common code across multiple projects, or working on large, modular applications where different teams maintain separate repositories over what Carthage offers.
Developers should use Carthage when they need a lightweight, non-intrusive dependency manager for Swift or Objective-C projects, especially in environments where they want to avoid modifying Xcode project files or prefer decentralized dependency management
Disagree with our pick? nice@nicepick.dev