Separate Mobile Sites vs Progressive Web Apps

Developers should learn about Separate Mobile Sites primarily for historical context, maintenance of legacy systems, or specific performance-critical scenarios where a lightweight mobile-only site is needed meets developers should learn pwas to build fast, reliable, and engaging web applications that work across all devices and platforms, without the need for app store distribution. Here's our take.

Separate Mobile Sites

Nice Pick

Developers should learn about Separate Mobile Sites primarily for historical context, maintenance of legacy systems, or specific performance-critical scenarios where a lightweight mobile-only site is needed

Pros

• It's useful when targeting very low-bandwidth environments or devices with severe hardware limitations, as it allows for extreme optimization
• Related to: responsive-web-design, progressive-web-apps

Cons

• Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case

Progressive Web Apps

Developers should learn PWAs to build fast, reliable, and engaging web applications that work across all devices and platforms, without the need for app store distribution

Pros

• They are ideal for businesses seeking to reach users with a single codebase, improve performance on slow networks, and enhance user retention through offline functionality and push notifications
• Related to: service-workers, web-app-manifest

Cons

• Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case

The Verdict

These tools serve different purposes. Separate Mobile Sites is a methodology while Progressive Web Apps is a concept. We picked Separate Mobile Sites based on overall popularity, but your choice depends on what you're building.

The Bottom Line

Separate Mobile Sites wins

Based on overall popularity. Separate Mobile Sites is more widely used, but Progressive Web Apps excels in its own space.