Top-Down Integration vs Sandwich Integration
Developers should use top-down integration when they need to test critical high-level functionality and system architecture early in the development cycle, such as in projects with well-defined hierarchical structures or when the main control logic is a priority meets developers should use sandwich integration when working on complex systems with well-defined middle layers, such as in modular or layered architectures, to efficiently test integration points without waiting for all components to be complete. Here's our take.
Top-Down Integration
Developers should use top-down integration when they need to test critical high-level functionality and system architecture early in the development cycle, such as in projects with well-defined hierarchical structures or when the main control logic is a priority
Top-Down Integration
Nice PickDevelopers should use top-down integration when they need to test critical high-level functionality and system architecture early in the development cycle, such as in projects with well-defined hierarchical structures or when the main control logic is a priority
Pros
- +It is particularly useful for identifying major design flaws quickly and for incremental development where lower-level modules are not yet fully implemented, as stubs can temporarily replace them
- +Related to: software-testing, integration-testing
Cons
- -Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case
Sandwich Integration
Developers should use Sandwich Integration when working on complex systems with well-defined middle layers, such as in modular or layered architectures, to efficiently test integration points without waiting for all components to be complete
Pros
- +It is particularly useful in projects where both high-level and low-level modules are developed concurrently, as it allows parallel testing and reduces stubs and drivers compared to pure top-down or bottom-up approaches
- +Related to: integration-testing, top-down-testing
Cons
- -Specific tradeoffs depend on your use case
The Verdict
Use Top-Down Integration if: You want it is particularly useful for identifying major design flaws quickly and for incremental development where lower-level modules are not yet fully implemented, as stubs can temporarily replace them and can live with specific tradeoffs depend on your use case.
Use Sandwich Integration if: You prioritize it is particularly useful in projects where both high-level and low-level modules are developed concurrently, as it allows parallel testing and reduces stubs and drivers compared to pure top-down or bottom-up approaches over what Top-Down Integration offers.
Developers should use top-down integration when they need to test critical high-level functionality and system architecture early in the development cycle, such as in projects with well-defined hierarchical structures or when the main control logic is a priority
Disagree with our pick? nice@nicepick.dev